: Hi, Beardilocks here to answer your question about uncorrupted variants of these skins. First let me start off by saying I love how passionate about Xayah and Rakan Star Guardians everyone has been! I can see that you guys love both their light and dark forms, and we have definitely heard your feedback that this is a feature that you would like. However, I'm afraid that it isn't quite as simple as it initially seems, as there are quite a few things to consider. Please bear with me and read the whole context of why we won't be able to provide these. When we set about designing the Star Guardians for this year, we knew we wanted to evolve the thematic and expand the storyline. Until now, there had not been any definite antagonist for the Star Guardians to fight against - just some slightly generic monsters invading the city. We chose to do this by establishing Zoe as a villain in the universe, and having Xayah and Rakan as fallen Guardians, whom she had corrupted with her evil. When we go about creating a new skin for a character we create 3 "Pillars": Core concepts about the identity of the skin that are like guiding principals that we always try to work in to every aspect of their character. For Star Guardian Xayah, these pillars were: - Corrupted former star guardian with **internal struggle** - Dark star guardian beauty/ beauty with an edge - Fierce warrior spirit As such, when we were making creative decisions about the design, animations, sound, visual effects and voice recording, we tried to make sure that we were representing at least one of these pillars. You can see that I have highlighted the **internal struggle** part of her first pillar, as this is the most important defining feature of this skin. In pretty much every ability, animation and recall, we were trying to play up the struggle between dark and light, between good and bad. You can see this in her spells - her W is her reveling in her dark power, using it to damage enemies. Her R is supposed to be the most exciting moment, and highlight of her gameplay, and so is the point where we create the most contrast, expelling out the darkness and returning her to her original light form. All her voice acting also reinforces this - her voice lines are a contrast to her normal ones, where she is a badass anime villain, especially taunting the _loser _Star Guardians of her former team. We also wanted to play up the dynamic between Xayah and Rakan in this struggle between good and evil. In both their solo and duo recalls we see Rakan trying to save Xayah from the darkness by taking it into himself, trying to sacrifice himself to save her, becoming even more dark and corrupted in the process. This all ties into the story of Star Guardian this year (more story details to come soon!), though I don't want to spoil anything more in that area. **If we were to simply put a light version chroma out of this skin it would remove the central pillar of this skin, the internal struggle between light and dark, and the thing that makes this skin a legendary.** It would mean that a lot of their spells would not make any sense. A light Star Guardian Xayah would turn dark when she uses W (which would be a big contrast), but she would not change at all when she did her Ult (which would feel less impactful than her W at that point). Rakan would fire darkness out of him when he did his W (which wouldn't make sense), and when he ulted he'd turn super dark and grow big evil wings. Their recalls would not make any sense either, as the whole aspect of corrupting darkness would be out of place, and there would be no emotional impact to Rakan trying to take the darkness from Xayah. Further more, none of the VO of them being evil would make sense either. Some players have suggested that they would be fine with stuff not making sense and I understand that, but I don't think everyone would feel that way. I welcome anyone who thinks _all_ players would let a "small" detail like most of their spells not making sense to go to read some of the responses of other players on the boards and twitter about minor details they don't like :( If we did commit to fixing all of these things so that they made sense for a light variant, we'd need to do entirely new visual and sound effects, new animations, new voiceover and new recalls. At that point, we would basically have to charge the price of a whole new skin, or to add these as a toggle they'd basically need to become ultimates, because it would take the same amount of development time as a whole new skin would. Deciding to do this would be something we would have to do at the start of development, not after they are revealed on PBE. Additionally, they would be alternate skins that don't really fit into the story that we're trying to tell this year, which might even potentially confuse players. I know you're super passionate about this, and it's something I think would have been awesome to see too, but if it was something we chose to do, I would definitely want to do it properly to do it justice. Instead we chose to focus on delivering dark, corrupted Star Guardians, which I think we did successfully, but I'm sorry if you're disappointed.
> [{quoted}](name=Riot Beardilocks,realm=PBE,application-id=AYQh7p7O,discussion-id=Yf0OzEyH,comment-id=00010004,timestamp=2019-08-29T01:53:54.004+0000) > I know you're super passionate about this, and it's something I think would have been awesome to see too, but if it was something we chose to do, I would definitely want to do it properly to do it justice. Instead we chose to focus on delivering dark, corrupted Star Guardians, which I think we did successfully, but I'm sorry if you're disappointed. I really love your work with the skins, it is my favourite theme, and I'm by no means trying to look the skins down. But my point here is that I can't help but feeling that it is kinda hypocritical to stick to the narrative in order to justify no "light" chromas, as we talk about a skinline with colors attached to every Star Guardian, based in lore, but you gave them chromas anyway. And by the way, a different color scheme to the light forms too. Why is Xayah neon pink if she is meant to be the green stone? Same with Rakan (Green-Blue) and Neeko (...Rainbow?). I understand the decision, and I can ultimately agree with it. It would feel awful that I pay for these skins if later you'll release the variants that I always liked more, compared to.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Elderwood and Infernal Chromas!
They look very nice, I really like them. But I honestly wonder... Why chromas for Infernal? Dark Star or Bloodmoon had similar feedback, because they tend to use the same kind of colors (dark red or blues, and purple, respectively), but it was fine anyway. Here I really struggle to realize those chromas refer to a "Infernal" skin if they are not fiery/red. Not trying to bash them, again they really look nice. I ask about them as a concept. They're not a personalization of the base skin, they look completely separate to me.
: What was super cool about the “Choose the next Illaoi skin” was at the time she had gone a long time without a skin since her release. So it enabled Illaoi mains to have a hand in choosing her next thematic after waiting for so long. Not everyone was happy with the final choice but it was the most popular among Illaoi mains of the 3 concepts. Ivern was in the exact same situation as Illoai and yet you guys let us vote on a Tristana skin, a champ who gets skins almost annually and has a large suite already to choose from I don’t get it
> [{quoted}](name=Psycho Wendigo,realm=PBE,application-id=AYQh7p7O,discussion-id=WeA5QOqA,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2019-03-28T16:10:07.910+0000)I don’t get it It's not that hard, and[ they already explained why. ](https://twitter.com/thejanellemj/status/1108153271212863488) The less skins/more impopular a champion is, the less valuable are the votes, hence they wanted to do this round for a champion with way more skins and a moderate pick and playrate. >Not everyone was happy with the final choice but it was the most popular among Illaoi mains of the 3 concepts. Not everyone sees it like you. I main Illaoi, but I voted for explorer. And because Resistance was the most voted option, I was left without a real option (because she only has launch Void skin before that). It's great they take the votes of people who main said champions in consideration, but even then, the frustration of seeing a concept you like and you'd pay for, but it does not win it's still there. If a champion already has more skins, at least I have something I may like, instead.
: Nexus Blitz PBE V2 - Map Changes and New Events
With all these items coming back for Nexus Blitz... is there any chance you can add Moonflair Spellblade here too? Cheap, useful and finished. {{item:3170}} I don't think it would be an issue, considering the Tenacity passive is unique and you can't stack it with neither Zephyr nor Merc Treads. I understand that other items like Lord Van Damm's/Wooglet's, or the Black Market Brawlers ones, are harder or not possible to bring back because they are tied to their game modes, or the icons were reused in other things, but this one looked like a missed chance to me.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Shurelya's Reverie
Wait, so are you going to change the icon? I **really** like the icon it has, the same it used to have. It's clear it is a golden crown, and it feels very good. Cheap purchase I'm loving in Rakan or Zilean, among others. If I were going to change an icon, I'd go with Twin Shadows (what's the icon, anyway? a bow? the two ghosts?).

Plusmine

Level 32 (PBE)
Lifetime Upvotes
Create a Discussion