: [CLOSED] PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Star Guardian Syndra!
Give her and soraka idle animations, its not that hard to do... plus the other skins have them ;-;
: I think adding Shisa to Soraka's silence would be good, like have him sit/float/stand on top of the spinning star at the center, and he could even spin with it if possible, but doesn't have too. Shisa looks small enough to fit in the middle of it, and It says he is overly protective, so I thought he could be protecting her by silencing her enemy's or something like that, and when it explodes he returns to her or just disappears which ever is more easier to animate. -edit- Soraka could also throw him out as she puts down the silence
> [{quoted}](name=Garp the Fist ,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=Gb5kAEj1,comment-id=000f,timestamp=2017-08-09T19:22:32.457+0000) > > I think adding Shisa to Soraka's silence would be good, like have him sit/float/stand on top of the spinning star at the center, and he could even spin with it if possible, but doesn't have too. Shisa looks small enough to fit in the middle of it, and It says he is overly protective, so I thought he could be protecting her by silencing her enemy's or something like that, and when it explodes he returns to her or just disappears which ever is more easier to animate. > > -edit- Soraka could also throw him out as she puts down the silence they should definetely do this, i legit dont see shisa in any part of her kit and it makes me a little upset
: That's fair! At this stage in the game, adding a new animation is a bit out of scope (adding new animations in most cases on PBE is out of scope, not just for this project). Adding new animations can take up to two weeks for more complex animations, which is longer than the PBE cycle, and that doesn't include testing and potential bug fixing! :o I hope we see Soraka with a legendary skin one day; I think a passive run has a lot of potential, but with the animations Star Guardian Soraka has, they aren't able to be implemented without interfering with gameplay. :c
> [{quoted}](name=Riot KateyKhaos,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=Gb5kAEj1,comment-id=0011000000000001,timestamp=2017-08-11T22:20:12.828+0000) > > That's fair! At this stage in the game, adding a new animation is a bit out of scope (adding new animations in most cases on PBE is out of scope, not just for this project). Adding new animations can take up to two weeks for more complex animations, which is longer than the PBE cycle, and that doesn't include testing and potential bug fixing! :o > > I hope we see Soraka with a legendary skin one day; I think a passive run has a lot of potential, but with the animations Star Guardian Soraka has, they aren't able to be implemented without interfering with gameplay. :c Could you please give soraka and syndra idle animations though, its a tiny animation that can be done easily especially since you guys are so talented (plus the other skins have them as well >.>)
: Will this new batch of skins have sound effects on their recalls similar to the Star Guardian skins from last year? I got the Janna skin from a chest and I honestly think the music that plays during her recall is the best part of the skin. It's super atmospheric and is something a lot of other skins don't get which is why I love it so much! ^_^
> [{quoted}](name=BlakiepugPBE,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=hLZHn9UX,comment-id=0001,timestamp=2017-08-09T02:56:46.143+0000) > > Will this new batch of skins have sound effects on their recalls similar to the Star Guardian skins from last year? I got the Janna skin from a chest and I honestly think the music that plays during her recall is the best part of the skin. It's super atmospheric and is something a lot of other skins don't get which is why I love it so much! ^_^ sameeee i love the music, i hope they add it
: Hey GHT ZeroJJ! Thanks a bunch for the feedback! To touch upon a couple of your points - > Model: More tail sparkles please! I've noticed that Pop Star Ahri has more sparkles so does Arcade Ahri. Also the whiskers is a MUST! As xXCryMeARiverXx mentioned below, we won't be adding whiskers to Star Guardian Ahri. > Dance: Would it be possible to add music into her dance? Like Arcade Ahri, that was quite nice. If not that's okay. The sound designer is discussing it with the team, but we haven't made a call as to if it's going to be added or not just yet. > Homeguard (Question): When she's on homeguard animation and you throw a q back to make her faster, is it normal for her to run while the q is coming back? I was just curious. I believe so, but I'll poke my animator to make sure. :P > R (ULT): When Ahri ults and she has this purple cosmic stars, it would be nice if it would fade away after 1 second use of ult (gets refreshed when used again). It can be used against her gameplay wise. She does already have an indicator of the ult on her feet but it's pretty much screaming 'I HAVE 2 MORE CHARGES OF ULT' kind of thing. We ran this one by gameplay and a designer and got the okay on this one, so it's likely it's going to remain as is.
> [{quoted}](name=Riot KateyKhaos,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=FZZiRqt4,comment-id=00160001,timestamp=2017-08-11T19:55:44.490+0000) > > Hey GHT ZeroJJ! > > Thanks a bunch for the feedback! > > To touch upon a couple of your points - > > As xXCryMeARiverXx mentioned below, we won't be adding whiskers to Star Guardian Ahri. > > The sound designer is discussing it with the team, but we haven't made a call as to if it's going to be added or not just yet. > > I believe so, but I'll poke my animator to make sure. :P > > We ran this one by gameplay and a designer and got the okay on this one, so it's likely it's going to remain as is. Music added to the dance would be soooo cool, I was wondering if this years star guardian skins could have the star guardian music added to their recalls like the others, or was that just because there was a music video released along with the skins last year?
: I honestly think she needs her whiskers to balance it out and look more "Ahri"
> [{quoted}](name=Nine Tailed Foxy,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=VAmB37Pm,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2017-08-10T09:34:30.097+0000) > > I honestly think she needs her whiskers to balance it out and look more "Ahri" exactly what i was gonna say but i dont think theyre gonna add her whiskers sadly, kateykhaos said it like 10 times that they werent
: Star Guardian skins
Give soraka and syndra idle animations like the others as well please, theyre all priced the same and dont feel its fair that 3 of the 5 have this and 2 dont even if its such a minor detail
: yeah, i don't like Soraka just standing there doing nothing :(
> [{quoted}](name=Moonboy65,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=IZXbpkhJ,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2017-08-12T22:09:58.289+0000) > > yeah, i don't like Soraka just standing there doing nothing :( Yeah same but the odds of riot seeing this thread are one in a million ;/
Rioter Comments
: > [{quoted}](name=Chinoumi,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=IeXlV3Iq,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2017-08-09T06:31:46.018+0000) > > Awesome skin. The animations and sound effects are really crisp, easy to play with and play against. The voice is a little off putting as some others have mentioned. The reverb doesn't fit well with the rest of the sounds and concept. > > One thing I'd like to bring to attention since we have a group of people working on a Syndra skin. There's a weird part of her turn animation, on all skins, where she stutters and kind of revolves around her z axis when you issue move commands left and right, or any opposite direction, which both looks really off and make it hard to read her movements, both playing as and against. (It's like she's the only champ with turn speed in her movement animations, it's hard to describe but easy to replicate) I find my self looking more at her hp bar for position than the actual model. > > There's some really great turn tech used for other champions, like Lucian but also newer releases. > Would it be possible to get your opinion on this matter? This has bothered me since Syndras release. Thank you~ That's interesting, sounds like it could be a long-standing bug. I'll see if I can reproduce it. Thanks for the note! (Removed other comment, was supposed to be an addendum to this one for visibility): not sure if there's anything we can do for this patch cycle, but I'll speak to some animators to see what can be done.
> [{quoted}](name=Riot Time Wizard,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=IeXlV3Iq,comment-id=00020000,timestamp=2017-08-11T01:33:24.244+0000) > > That's interesting, sounds like it could be a long-standing bug. I'll see if I can reproduce it. Thanks for the note! Is there any way you could give syndra and soraka idle animations as well? Ezreal and miss fortune have them and of course ahri due to the fact that her skin is legendary. I feel it's not too much to ask for and I know you guys are capable b/c youre amazing like look at this skin, okey dokey ttyl
: Dont you think that this skin could become so much more and all that was required was like little changes, like the furry thing, toggle mask ect. I'm happy that Diana got her Blood Moon finally but I'm sad at the same time watching how a good potential is wasted.
> [{quoted}](name=509,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=MGJmrmLH,comment-id=00270001,timestamp=2017-02-07T20:19:46.381+0000) > > Dont you think that this skin could become so much more and all that was required was like little changes, like the furry thing, toggle mask ect. I'm happy that Diana got her Blood Moon finally but I'm sad at the same time watching how a good potential is wasted. retweet
: I love when Riot ignores good feedback <3 (In regards to her face, the mask on her ult, and the flute missing especially) =)
ikr im disappointed the mask being a toggle wouldve had more people buying it
: sooo all that feedback you guys got was mostly ignored? the only change was the adding more colors to her sword and making her skin pale (that's why we can't have nice things for Diana)? there goes my hype for that skin :/ at least she got beautiful splash art
i feel the same, i really think they couldve added a toggle for her mask and maybe cleaned up her face but who am i kidding im still gonna throw my money in their face and buy it ;-;
: Hi everyone!! First of all, this skin is gorgeous and is a real work of art I must say. I understand how riot feels about the toggle for the mask, but I think it would be a great idea overall. If you guys go through with it, i noticed that in her recall her eyes are very odd-looking and possibly you could change it so they could glow red? Also, in my opinion i think her hair could use a touch up because in the splash it looks a tiny bit smoother than her model in game. You guys did amazing and I cant express how impressed and amazed by how it turned out ( exactly how I felt when you released elementalist lux OMG). Anyways really looking forward to this skin and IM PRAYING for that toggle!
Also maybe you guys could add some red highlights to her roots like in the splash, might make it look even more amazing
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Blood Moon Diana!
Hi everyone!! First of all, this skin is gorgeous and is a real work of art I must say. I understand how riot feels about the toggle for the mask, but I think it would be a great idea overall. If you guys go through with it, i noticed that in her recall her eyes are very odd-looking and possibly you could change it so they could glow red? Also, in my opinion i think her hair could use a touch up because in the splash it looks a tiny bit smoother than her model in game. You guys did amazing and I cant express how impressed and amazed by how it turned out ( exactly how I felt when you released elementalist lux OMG). Anyways really looking forward to this skin and IM PRAYING for that toggle!
: As do i, my friend and I were trying out the new champ on a custom match and the servers went offline due to maintenance/update and now the update is installed and servers are back up and I am also stuck trying to reconnect to a non-existing game. Please fix this. {{sticker:slayer-pantheon-thumbs}}
i have to study for 3 tests i just wanna squeeze in one elementalist lux game :(
: This is fustrating I didnt even play 12 min of the game and it went offline today is bad luck for me{{sticker:zombie-brand-mindblown}}
i downloaded PBE today, got in a game for 2 mins then d/ced, i didnt even get to kill anyone with elementalist lux :C
: Stuck in "Game in process"
yea same i really wanted to play elementalist lux lol i just got PBE today
: Stuck on reconnecting after update

Keori

Level 30 (PBE)
Lifetime Upvotes
Create a Discussion