: [CLOSED] PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Star Guardian Miss Fortune!
  Rioter Comments
: [CLOSED] PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Battle Boss Malzahar!
The VFX are amazing. Love the binary on his E especially. The model colouring could use a bit of work. A bit too purple like his base. Maybe more red?
: Hey, I appreciate the feedback! There are a few things here I can take back to the team for discussion. Regarding audio, there will be new SFX on Q, W, E and R. As noted in the original thread, E and R are not on PBE at the moment, nor are the SFX for her recall. Her AAs will sound similar to base, but will be different; at the end of the day, they're both metal swords!
Thanks for the response. Her Q and W sound like they're using the default SFX right now. Will those be coming at a later date as well?
: [CLOSED] PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Pentakill Kayle!
Hi, Does she/will she have new SFX for Q and W? If not, sorry, but 1350 is looking a bit overpriced for this. Even if I love her hair. Oh, the AA animation really needs to be sorted out. -edit. Just tried it out for a few minutes. It absolutely must receive new SFX on all skills to justify the current price, IMO. Given her archaic animations the skin just feels... not great. Get some AS and the AA animation in particular is just dreadful. The halo on her E could use some work. Zoomed in I can see it's a chain but from a normal distance it looks like a rotating burnt doughnut.
Rioter Comments
: [Closed] PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Heartseeker Quinn!
Any chance of her getting some new SFX on the other skills (Q, E & R)? Maybe something in a similar vein to Heartseeker Ashe's "shimmery" SFX? Or more "dovey" in this case, I guess? I feel like it's about time Quinn got a 1350-tier quality skin! Having just one new sound always leaves me with the impression of a skin being incomplete.
: [ULTIMATE SKIN] PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread - Elementalist Lux!
> [{quoted}](name=Riot KateyKhaos,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=NksGHs8c,comment-id=,timestamp=2016-11-08T20:33:44.694+0000) > > In addition to **Elementalist Lux**, corresponding icons for each form and a similarly themed ward skin will be available via several options. We’ll drop more details about this later, but in the meantime, please feel free to focus your testing and feedback efforts on **Elementalist Lux** herself! Ummm... I hope this doesn't mean we're going to have to pay for the icons separately.
: > [{quoted}](name=Eva,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=fnGEu1kl,comment-id=0003,timestamp=2016-10-05T03:36:50.590+0000) > > Absolutely agree that the spell effects are too purple. > > I signed in just to reiterate that point. > > The Q looks good because it has that nice orangey yellow hue at its heart with purple to complement. > > The rest of the VFX though are a majority purple which is just so tired and overused. > > Add. More. Orange. Thanks for the feedback, Eva! We've been hearing this a lot like you mentioned. We're discussing ways to tweak the VFX at the moment.
> [{quoted}](name=Riot LoveStrut,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=fnGEu1kl,comment-id=00030000,timestamp=2016-10-05T05:53:26.218+0000) > > Thanks for the feedback, Eva! > > We've been hearing this a lot like you mentioned. We're discussing ways to tweak the VFX at the moment. Hi, Can we get an update?
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Bewitching Morgana!
Absolutely agree that the spell effects are too purple. I signed in just to reiterate that point. The Q looks good because it has that nice orangey yellow hue at its heart with purple to complement. The rest of the VFX though are a majority purple which is just so tired and overused. Add. More. Orange.
: Is that her original voice actress doing her new lines? o.o
> [{quoted}](name=Amy Sery,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=VRnyEqEr,comment-id=0002,timestamp=2016-09-20T19:52:24.584+0000) > > Is that her original voice actress doing her new lines? o.o I'm pretty sure it is.
: PROJECT: Ashe // ACTIVATE PBE TESTING
Prefer the splash art version without the mask.
: PROJECT: Katarina // ACTIVATE PBE TESTING
Needs PROJECT-y particles for her movement speed boost.
: PROJECT: Ashe // ACTIVATE PBE TESTING
Her bow reminds me of DJ Sona's instrument thing.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Pool Party Miss Fortune!
A couple of things. The hat - I agree w/ the above that it's a bit much. The swimsuit - it's a bit... weird. It's trying to walk a fine line between sexy and modest and not really working, IMO. -edit. Just played with it for a few minutes. Further critiques - the outfit colour with all the navy blue is just very bland to me. It doesn't feel summery at all. I've already mentioned that the design does nothing for me. Nothing about it stands out. On a positive note, her recall animation is perfect.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Pool Party Fiora!
Totally unexpected surprise to get Pool Party Fiora. Adore the colour scheme and especially the orange-purple gradient for her "towel cape" or whatever it is, lol... The hair is interesting even if having shaved sides is a bit overdone lately. The outfit is cute. -edit. Spent a couple of minutes playing with it. The recall animation is absolutely perfect and the kick at the end caught me off guard in a great way. Love it. The squeak SFX on her E and the seagull SFX on her ult are fantastic. My only critique would be her passive indicator on enemy champions is a bit too dull and faint in colour. Maybe I'm too used to PROJECT's super-readable one though. Could this be looked at please? All things considered 9.9/10!
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Super Galaxy Kindred!
This skin should absolutely be renamed to Neon Strike. It has much more in common with that line than 'Super Galaxy' or whatever. In fact, I barely see any similarities to tie it to that particular aesthetic (SG).
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Infernal Diana!
Just tried it out. The VFX (and the SFX mostly) are great. Very fiery and convey the right "feel", IMO. The model is a pretty straight-forward take on "deadly-sexy" but it works. I like it a lot, actually. Criticism - the hair. I was expecting a flowing mane of flame as her hair is pretty much a signature element of her design. Right now though? It looks like a flickering candle about to die out. Can someone amp it up a bit? Or, preferably, a lot?
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Infernal Diana!
I usually find fire-themed (and ice-themed) skins trite but this actually looks very nice. Looking forward to trying it out.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Program Lissandra!
Honestly, this is pretty much a perfect skin, IMO. I can't fault a single aspect. Love the robotic/digital theme and it really worked for Lissandra. As with Soraka, the voice filter, for once, actually added a lot - just the right note of creepy robot.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Mecha Zero Sion!
The sound effects for his auto-attacks feel very ineffectual. I was expecting something weighty and crunching but instead it was like... a gentle tapping.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Program Soraka!
Just played around with it a little bit. Really, really, really great job. Especially on the voice processing which, for once, feels like a significant change rather than just minimal, weird reverb effects. The VFX really stand out as new and different too, which I like. The colour scheme is perfect, IMO. I also like that this "Program" line feels like an AP counterpart to the AD-heavy "PROJECT" line so far.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Program Soraka!
: Nah, ARAM queues are pretty deserted :c
> [{quoted}](name=Amy Sery,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=F6Uac5Uq,comment-id=0000,timestamp=2016-03-08T22:47:00.423+0000) > > Nah, ARAM queues are pretty deserted :c Oh... and it's the only queue they're giving us! Lol. -edit. The queue finally pops and the game won't start. Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh.
Rioter Comments
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Meowkai!
Just took a quick look in-game. The sound effects on his emotes are possibly the cutest you've ever done. Love them. The VFX are great, the model is great, and so is the recall animation. The skin is pretty much perfect! The only complaint I could make is that it's not an ultimate skin. Maokai's voice/lines with the skin is a bit jarring. Also, a slight bug - his old emote SFX, like laugh, can be heard when you spam while moving.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Meowkai!
I need this skin. Like right now. Ahhh! Please don't have a shared splash though!!!
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Elderwood Leblanc!
The splash art is so pretty! Good job!
: ​ ​PBE Bugs (heh.. bug.. Kha'Zix) & Feedback Thread: Death Blossom Kha'Zix​
I guess "Death Blossom" is like... a companion line to the "Elderwood" skins now? Really love how colourful the models are.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Elderwood Leblanc!
Reminds me of River Spirit Nami. Colour-wise.
: Hextech Annie, crafting and gemstones
This hextech system is getting a little confusing.
: Hey Cantaloupe Cake - Thanks for the honest feedback. The name Heartseeker/Sweetheart is determined based on the personality of a champion, as opposed to the weapon they wield. *c/p from another reply on this post* - We took in the personalities of both Sona and Orianna. Sona is more passive, and more, well, sweet. Orianna is a robot (does she even have a heart, and if not, is she seeking one?) and would definitely be more aggressive and more of a killer-type than Sona would.
> [{quoted}](name=Riot KateyKhaos,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=91rl4lEb,comment-id=000f0002,timestamp=2016-01-28T20:43:02.927+0000) > > Hey Cantaloupe Cake - > > Thanks for the honest feedback. > > The name Heartseeker/Sweetheart is determined based on the personality of a champion, as opposed to the weapon they wield. > > *c/p from another reply on this post* - We took in the personalities of both Sona and Orianna. Sona is more passive, and more, well, sweet. Orianna is a robot (does she even have a heart, and if not, is she seeking one?) and would definitely be more aggressive and more of a killer-type than Sona would. So, theoretically, the fantasy of this skin might be that Orianna is out to get a heart for herself by way of murder/organ harvest? Cool!
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Heartseeker Orianna!
I just realized there are literally 20+ hearts on Orianna's model. Kind of OD'd on those, lol!
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Heartseeker Orianna!
Her facial expression (okay, more like just her mouth opening wide) during the recall animation cracks me up! Love it. :O
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Sweetheart Sona!
After seeing it in motion my only real complaint is it looks like she abused her flat iron. It almost doesn't read as hair since it looks completely flat. Almost like ribbons. Maybe fill it out a little? Some volume...
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Heartseeker Orianna!
Looks really cute. Can't wait to try it.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Beast Hunter Sejuani, Draven, and Tryndamere!
: PBE Content Being Removed for Loot System Testing
Pool Party Renekton's skin shard is displaying Scorched Earth Renekton's splash in the preview thing.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Beast Hunter Sejuani, Draven, and Tryndamere!
Love Sejuani's model and especially Bristle's. Could you clarify what were the "quality of life particles" though? I can't spot a difference between these effects and the default...
: Not necessarily. See here: http://na.leagueoflegends.com/en/news/store/sales/were-changing-discounts The relevant clause (just below the table in the "Introducing the early sale!" section) reads "Bringing all of our skins onto the same early sale schedule means there will no longer be a launch sale for 1350s and Ultimates starting in the new year". Since legacy skins aren't in the shop 4-6 months after their release, it's not apparent to me when they'd be eligible for an early sale, and I'd appreciate it if we could get some clarity on the issue.
> [{quoted}](name=Chrysippus,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=mgMe9s5k,comment-id=000600000000,timestamp=2015-12-20T15:54:30.587+0000) > > Not necessarily. See here: http://na.leagueoflegends.com/en/news/store/sales/were-changing-discounts > > The relevant clause (just below the table in the "Introducing the early sale!" section) reads "Bringing all of our skins onto the same early sale schedule means there will no longer be a launch sale for 1350s and Ultimates starting in the new year". Since legacy skins aren't in the shop 4-6 months after their release, it's not apparent to me when they'd be eligible for an early sale, and I'd appreciate it if we could get some clarity on the issue. Wow. That's the first I'm reading of this and it leaves me with a really bitter taste. Clearly the PROJECT skin "promotion" was simply testing how receptive we'd be to paying full price on release for 1350 tier content and nothing more. Lol@"we want to offer collectible content." Previously I'd go out of my way to buy skins on release that I liked but wasn't necessarily dying to have solely because of the launch sales. Now? I'm probably going to just skip them altogether on principle. This excessive corporate greed is a real turn-off.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Lunar Wraith Caitlyn!
Agreed that this skin is crying out for a voice filter or something. She's supposed to be a wraith............
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Lunar Wraith Morgana!
With this skin I can kind of see why characters with old models are avoided for new skins. This looks extremely dated with the poor animation and, I guess, frame beneath. Other than that, the colour of her skirt just really bothers me. It's like a drabness that's totally unappealing. I don't really expect it to change seeing as it matches the particles but ehhh... just not to my taste, I suppose.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Lunar Wraith Caitlyn!
Please no shared splash.... pleaaaaaaaaase.................
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Challenger Nidalee!
Gorgeous, even in the model viewer preview thing. And pink particles? Instant buy.
: Negative feedback is absolutely fine, however, would you mind tying it back to reasoning behind why you dislike it and how you'd change it? Would you be more okay with the splash if they were interacting with each other? When is it acceptable for a skin to share a splash with other skins?
> [{quoted}](name=Riot KateyKhaos,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=AM6WIHaA,comment-id=001e0000,timestamp=2015-12-03T17:39:14.724+0000) > > Negative feedback is absolutely fine, however, would you mind tying it back to reasoning behind why you dislike it and how you'd change it? > > Would you be more okay with the splash if they were interacting with each other? When is it acceptable for a skin to share a splash with other skins? I thought I was pretty explicit in my reasoning for disliking it...? But okay. A) Splash art, to me, factors into the pricing of a skin. So, having shared art for skins that are already on the high-end of the RP scale smacks of laziness and trying to economize on effort. I've previously seen red posters lament the work necessary for these but when you're charging $10 and up for a single skin, I'm sorry, but don't cut corners. Further, if I wanted to buy more than one of these skins, I'd be paying for the same piece of art repeatedly. Unacceptable, IMO. B) I've also seen some justification from reds saying these shared pieces help enhance the theme when multiple skins are released at once. I can maybe agree to an extent if the art depicts some meaningful interaction between characters. You know, maybe they were having a snowball fight, building a snowman, I don't know, something along those lines. But this Snow Day splash? They're simply there. Kind of positioned nearby one another. That's it. There's no real reason for them to even be in the same piece other than saving an artist some work. There's no enhancement of any "Snow Day theme" whatsoever. C) These group splashes, with a couple of exceptions, are very clearly of lower quality than those featuring a single character. Compare Syndra's depiction in the Snow Day art to Elderwood Hecarim or Gravelord Azir, for instance. Can you imagine a combined PROJECT artwork? We wouldn't have gotten those amazing quality (super detailed, dynamic and interesting) individual pieces. Even compare this shared art to 2013's or 2014's Snowdown skins. Quite a gulf. Anyway, the only case where I would maybe (and this is a pretty tenuous maybe) be okay with shared art is for 750 RP skins or lower. Wait... are there even any lower than 750 RP anymore...? Even then I'd still probably skip out on them because of principle.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Snow Day Syndra!
The whole splash is terrible. Expensive skins sharing a single art? Not even a very good quality piece with them interacting in any meaningful way? Just huddled up? Lazy and sloppy. I hate this trend so much.
: Hello! First of all I'd like to congratulate you guys for these amazing skins. I have yet to see the particles on Snow Day Syndra, but I can say the model looks great. I can totally picture syndra being someone who would choose to wear a big fur coat with fur ugg boots. It's a great way to represent the champion in another theme without losing its personality. The colors on the coat, dress and scarf are great and form a really pretty color scheme, but I think the hair color is a bit too plain. It's almost the same tone on the entire length of the hair, maybe you could try making it a little lighter on the top and keep it dark on the tips? It wouldn't exactly be an ombré, more like a brighter lightning as it gets closer to the player's point of view. I made a small edit in case I'm not expressing myself clearly enough: http://i.imgur.com/D9Ngi8W.png The left is unaltered, while the right is brighter on the top part of the hair. Besides that, I tested a few other hair colors and found out Auburn looks amazing on syndra on that specific skin, but I don't know if changing the hair color completely is a too big of a change, or even unnecesary. But if you guys are open to it, I think it shines her strong character even more, besides being a pleasant color scheme: http://i.imgur.com/waE7q1Z.png Regardless, my friend and I are definitely buying that skin as we love syndra and are very happy she had the opportunity to be part of the Snowdown skins set. Thanks! P/S: Are we allowed to know if all three skins (Snow Day Syndra, Bard and Gnar) will have shared splashes? Just a curiosity, as they share the same name. Thanks again!
> [{quoted}](name=Paris Hilton,realm=PBE,application-id=cMKtzQHY,discussion-id=AM6WIHaA,comment-id=0003,timestamp=2015-11-23T21:51:47.451+0000) > > Hello! First of all I'd like to congratulate you guys for these amazing skins. > > I have yet to see the particles on Snow Day Syndra, but I can say the model looks great. I can totally picture syndra being someone who would choose to wear a big fur coat with fur ugg boots. It's a great way to represent the champion in another theme without losing its personality. > > The colors on the coat, dress and scarf are great and form a really pretty color scheme, but I think the hair color is a bit too plain. It's almost the same tone on the entire length of the hair, maybe you could try making it a little lighter on the top and keep it dark on the tips? It wouldn't exactly be an ombré, more like a brighter lightning as it gets closer to the player's point of view. I made a small edit in case I'm not expressing myself clearly enough: > > http://i.imgur.com/D9Ngi8W.png > > The left is unaltered, while the right is brighter on the top part of the hair. > > Besides that, I tested a few other hair colors and found out Auburn looks amazing on syndra on that specific skin, but I don't know if changing the hair color completely is a too big of a change, or even unnecesary. But if you guys are open to it, I think it shines her strong character even more, besides being a pleasant color scheme: > http://i.imgur.com/waE7q1Z.png > > Regardless, my friend and I are definitely buying that skin as we love syndra and are very happy she had the opportunity to be part of the Snowdown skins set. Thanks! > > > P/S: Are we allowed to know if all three skins (Snow Day Syndra, Bard and Gnar) will have shared splashes? Just a curiosity, as they share the same name. Thanks again! I agree about the auburn hair. It looks wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy better than the dull, brassy brown that it is now. Consider changing it!
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Void Bringer Illaoi!
A bit disappointed with the splash. It looks very stiff and unnatural as well as flat. Seems like something you'd find as an amateur fan art on DA or something.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Void Bringer Illaoi!
Is it just me or would 'Voidbringer' look a bit better? It would follow the naming convention established by the 'Dragonslayer' and 'Heartseeker' skins as well as 'Soulstealer Vladimir.' I'm sure there are others I'm forgetting as well.
: PBE Bugs & Feedback Thread: Dragon Trainer Tristana!
Easily the most adorable skin you've come up with. Every single animation is almost too cute to bear, lol... Great job!!!
Show more

Eva

Level 30 (PBE)
Lifetime Upvotes
Create a Discussion